Foundation-Funded News: The State of Research

Martin Scott

April 2, 2019

Blog

TO HELP THOSE WANTING TO LEARN MORE ABOUT THIS AREA, WE HAVE PRODUCED AN OVERVIEW OF THE EXISTING RESEARCH INTO FOUNDATION-FUNDED JOURNALISM. THIS LISTS THE MAIN PUBLICATIONS TO DATE, THE METHODS USED AND THE MAIN FINDINGS.

Research into foundation-funded journalism is relatively scarce and disconnected. There is, for example, no single edited volume on this topic.

This matters because while philanthropists and foundations often want to support journalism, it is not always clear how they should do this. Similarly, journalists are often unsure about common practices in this area.

For those interested in carrying out further research in this area, this matters because it is useful to know what methods have been used to study this topic in the past and how their findings compare to others.

We are certain that this list is incomplete, though. So please get in touch to let us know what is missing – we intend to produce updated versions as further research is published.

There are three key characteristics of research in this are:

1. Most of the research is US centric. This is partly because, as Eric Karstens explains, ‘charitable journalism funding largely remains a US affair – both in terms of donors and beneficiaries’. According to data from Media Impact Funders, ‘more than 90 per cent of grant money flows to US-based organizations, with some 6 per cent of funds allocated to Europe, and only about 1 per cent to media outlets in the developing world… The vast majority of foundations engaging in the sector are also based in the US’.

2. A number of the studies listed here rely upon data held by Media Impact Funders for their analysis. The other dominant methodology is interviews or surveys of journalists and representatives of foundations. By contrast, there are very few ethnographic studies of specific cases of foundation-funded journalism, or systematic analyses of news content itself. As Harry Browne puts it, ‘there has not, as yet, been any comprehensive content analysis of the work produced by foundation-funded journalists’

3. By far the greatest concern of existing research is about how foundation funding may affect journalistic independence or autonomy. Other common issues addressed include the volume and sustainability of funding, the consequences of an ‘impact agenda’ and the effects of foundation funding on the role perceptions and ‘boundaries’ of journalism.

Related Posts

Why did Epstein fund non-profit media?

Kate Wright

August 23, 2019

Blog

Journalists working for non-profits tend to only think about ethics in terms of preventing donors from influencing their content and don't consider the circumstances in which they might cut ties with a donor.

Read More

Humanitarian journalism research in the news

Martin Scott

February 20, 2019

Blog

A summary of recent news coverage of our humanitarian journalism research.

Read More

Popular Articles

Twitter

I’ve just tallied up all the tasks (65 of them!) we are expected to carry out in relation to teaching each year, many newly introduced and with no time allocated for learning the system, or for developing and improving. No wonder we’re all at breaking point. These include: 1/n

One week left to apply for the @nesta_uk #FutureNewsFund, so if you:
- have an idea for how to reinvent or transform public interest news
- are a UK-registered company, cooperative, CIC, charity or other kind of organisation
go here:
https://www.nesta.org.uk/project/future-news-fund/call-ideas/

Hope @EdinburghUni will follow suit. Their decision to make all strike deductions in January looks petty & punitive in contrast #UCUStrikesBack https://twitter.com/strathclydeucu/status/1202352624546267138

Strathclyde #UCUStrikesBack@StrathclydeUCU

Some good news for #StrathStrikers

Deductions over three months, instead of the planned two.

Shows goodwill on the part of @UniStrathclyde

Hope other unis will follow suit.

#UCUStrikesBack