How does donor funding influence humanitarian journalism?

JonEilenberg

May 18, 2017

Blog

IJPP 1By Jon Eilenberg. Humanitarian reporting has never been lucrative, and with the ongoing decline in budgets and the squeezing of newsrooms resources, news organisations have had to explore new sources of funding. One way of addressing this issue is through foundation funding, but with this comes discussions regarding donor influence. However, this is an under-researched area, and there is a lack of concrete evidence about how donor and journalistic power are negotiated.

One of the only studies to grapple with these questions is presented in an article recently published by Martin Scott, Mel Bunce, and Kate Wright. They provide a detailed case study of the humanitarian news organisation IRIN between November 2014 and November 2015. In this period, IRIN transitioned from being involved with the UN – to being funded by the Jynwel Foundation – to being an independent non-profit association.

The contention of the article is that foundations can potentially influence journalism in the same ways as ownership (following a model by Benson, Hesserus and Sedel). Whilst evidence of direct editorial influence is rare, foundations can potentially shape a news organisations’ target audience, commitment to public service values and the political or economic interests it serves. To examine exactly how these indirect influences can play out, the researchers analysed IRIN’s news outputs, editorial meetings and strategy documents and interviewed all journalists and editors.

IRIN’s changing funding status did have some effect on their news output: the number of news stories and the use of social media both increased while the length of their articles decreased. In terms of content, however, IRIN’s coverage did not become more campaign-oriented or pro-market. The causes of these effects are described in the article as divided into three areas, which reflect the target audience, political or economic interests, and public service values mentioned above.

The first cause was that IRIN began to focus on maximising their audience reach, which was linked to the increased number of shorter news stories. The second cause was competing agendas and cultural differences between journalism, humanitarianism, and philanthro-capitalism, which led to a difficult balancing act for the news workers. The third influence was the agency of the editors and journalists at IRIN – who maintained their editorial independence.

In conclusion, Scott, Bunce, and Wright’s article shows that, in the case of IRIN, donor power operated entirely indirectly and always in concert with the professional values of the news organisation. Journalistic culture and agency, and the context in which they are exercised, remain central to the production of humanitarian news. Whilst more research is needed, this study strongly suggests that it is not just a simple case of the donor playing the tune that news organisations follow.

Dr Jon Østergaard Eilenberg

City, University of London

The article ‘Donor Power and the News – The Influence of Foundation Funding on International Public Service Journalism’ is available open access in the ‘International Journal of Press Politics’: http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1940161217693394

Related Posts

Foundation-Funded Journalism: The State of Research

Martin Scott

April 2, 2019

Blog

An overview of research into foundation-funded journalism that lists the main publications, their methods and findings.

Read More

Humanitarian journalism research in the news

Martin Scott

February 20, 2019

Blog

A summary of recent news coverage of our humanitarian journalism research.

Read More

Twitter

Red Nose Day 2019: How Does It Work, And Why Is It Being Criticized? https://t.co/qk1gMx583N @MalakaGharib with a good overview for @NPRGoatsandSoda (Also, get her new book)

Thousands of comms scholars arrive in DC for #ica19, get this tornado warning and worry... is the local media really funded enough to perform this task?

Want to be Director of Research at the @BritishAcademy_? https://t.co/lI3z3leaFC #humanities #socialscience #scipol