‘Doing good’ and ‘looking good’ in global humanitarian reporting (Book chapter)

Martin Scott

September 16, 2017

Publication

By Martin Scott (@martinscott2010). This chapter investigates if and how a private donor’s apparent motivation to ‘look good’ – or to generate symbolic capital – interacts with a news organization’s ability to ‘do good’ by producing public service content. We address this issue by reporting on the findings of a year-long study of the online humanitarian news organisation – IRIN – as it became primarily funded by a new donor. We argue that whilst it is possible that the Foundation’s pursuit of symbolic capital may have had some effect on how IRIN sought to ‘do good’, it did not appear to affect the extent to which IRIN was either willing or able to ‘do good’. Indeed, our analysis makes clear that the influence of the Foundation only had an effect on IRIN when it combined with other factors, especially journalists’ own values and organizational strategies. Ultimately, this case highlights the limits of generalized claims about the likely influence of a donor’s desire to ‘look good’ on a news organization.

 

The chapter, ‘‘Doing good’ and ‘looking good’ in global humanitarian reporting’ (Scott, Bunce and Wright) is forthcoming (2018) in Communication in International Development: ‘Doing good or looking good? (Enghel & Noske-Turner (eds.))

Related Posts

Slack, virtual newsrooms and journalistic practice (Article)

Mel Bunce

January 10, 2018

Publication

By Mel Bunce (@meljbunce). Virtual newsrooms have enormous potential: enabling journalists around the world to pool their knowledge, skills and perspectives within joint projects, such as the Panama Papers. These virtual newsrooms are supported by Online Collaborative Software (OCS), the most popular of which is Slack. But although many of the world’s top news organisations […]

Read More

Foundation-funded Journalism, Philanthro-capitalism and Tainted Donors (Article)

Kate Wright

January 9, 2018

Publication

By Kate Wright (@newsprof1). Not-for-profit news organisations are increasingly funded by private foundations, supported by wealthy entrepreneurs. This raises a range of ethical dilemmas for journalists, which are particularly serious when their donors are alleged to have been involved in unethical or illegal activities. Although this is a relatively common occurrence in the non-profit sector, […]

Read More

Twitter

Kevin Merkelz, DEV Alumni from 2013, who works as a Humanitarian Aid Worker for the UN, shares his expirence of working in camp management during emergency responses. #WID18 #ueadev

Fantastic internship opportunities at humanitarian news org @irinnews please pass on to journalism students & graduates https://t.co/QW93018iRZ